Pakatan vs Pakatan on Lynas issue

MORE ABOUT LYNAS ANYONE?

In mole.my:

http://mole.my/content/pakatan-vs-pakatan-lynas

Non-Dr-non-scientist Fuziah of PKR said:

"I did not only consult the nuclear expert on this project. I had discussed with geologists, environmentalists, public health experts and many more.

"When we talk about Lynas we talk about all angles and not only from radiation or the nuclear aspect of it," she said.

NUCLEAR SCIENTIST DR.CHE ROSLI (of PAS) said,
Dr Che Rosli on the other has been firm in his view that Lynas was safe and that it should be allowed to continue as long as the company adhered to the stringent guidelines set by the authorities.

However, Dr Che Rosli played down the possibilities of having a debate with Fuziah, fearing that the issue will be politicised.

“Let her debate with the Atomic Energy Licensing Board instead. I don’t want to prolong the issue nor do I want it to be politicised,” the former head of Nuclear Science Department for Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia said.

In August last year Dr Che Rosli had criticised PKR and Pas’ news letter Harakah for misleading reports on Lynas.


In Islam, as the saying goes:

ADA KAH SAMA ORANG YANG BERILMU DENGAN ORANG YANG TIDAK BERILMU?

In another blog, THEUNSPINNERS posted this:

"Menurut Pensyarah Program Sains Nuklear Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia , Profesor Dr. Ismail Bahari, radiasi hanya membahayakan manusia apabila ia melebihi paras tertentu dengan 100 mSv boleh menyebabkan meningkatnya risiko mendapat kanser.

Menurut Profesor Dr. Ismail lagi operasi Lynas hanya akan menyebabkan pendedahan radiasi kepada orang awam sebanyak 0.002mSv setahun dan ia 10 kali lebih rendah berbanding pendedahan radiasi menonton televisyen selama empat jam sehari untuk tempoh setahun.

Ada faham ke Prufesok Fuziah Salleh dan cicak-cicak mengkarung PKR ? 10 kali lebih rendah dari menonton televisyen..

"Profesor Dr. Ismail juga berkata, pendedahan radiasi kepada paru-paru apabila merokok sekotak sehari setiap hari selama setahun adalah 150 mSv atau 75,000 kali ganda lebih tinggi berbanding pendedahan radiasi daripada operasi Lynas.


Other readings:

1) http://mole.my/content/dr-mahathir-lynas
2) http://theunspinners.blogspot.com/2012/02/guan-eng-lakukan-provokasi-perkauman.html [Dia besar kepala pasal Cina ramai. Adakah apabila dia lagi berkuasa orang macam gini akan peduli Melayu?]
3) http://theunspinners.blogspot.com/2012/02/pengetahuan-fuziah-tentang-lynas.html